Stocks or Property, Beyond the Numbers

When it comes to investing in Singapore, the debate between stocks and property is a common one. While many articles focus on historical returns, tax implications, and liquidity, they often overlook the investor’s personality behind the decision. Your individual traits, such as risk tolerance, patience, fear management, and starting capital, significantly influence whether stocks or property are a better fit for you.

This article delves beyond the numbers to examine how these characteristics influence your investment decisions. Additionally, we expand the discussion on stocks beyond the Straits Times Index (STI) to include global options, such as the S&P 500, Nasdaq, and the Magnificent 7, markets that Singaporeans are increasingly investing in. Don’t forget to try our interactive calculator to assess your investment personality!

Understanding the Investment Landscape

Let’s explore the investment options available to Singaporean investors, starting locally and then expanding globally.

Stocks: From STI to Global Markets

Straits Times Index (STI): The STI tracks Singapore’s top 30 companies and has historically provided solid long-term returns, often outpacing property over the decades. However, it can be volatile, has limited new listings, and is exposed to global economic shifts, which can challenge investors. Despite this, its liquidity and accessibility through platforms like Tiger Brokers or moomoo make it a popular choice.

S&P 500: This U.S. index includes 500 leading companies, offering diversification across sectors such as technology, healthcare, and finance. Over the past 50 years, it has averaged around 10% annual returns (before inflation), but it is also subject to sharp fluctuations—such as during the 2008 financial crisis and the 2020 pandemic drop. Singaporeans can invest in this index through ETFs like the SPDR S&P 500 (SPY) via local brokers.

Nasdaq: Known for its focus on technology, the Nasdaq includes major companies like Apple, Microsoft, and Tesla. It has delivered impressive growth, with over 15% annualized returns in the past decade, but its volatility is higher than that of the S&P 500. Singaporean investors often access this market through Nasdaq-100 ETFs (e.g., QQQ) to benefit from this innovation-driven sector.

Magnificent 7: This elite group—comprising Apple, Microsoft, Alphabet (Google), Amazon, Nvidia, Tesla, and Meta—has driven much of the U.S. market’s growth. In 2023 alone, these companies accounted for over 60% of the S&P 500’s gains, largely fueled by trends in artificial intelligence and technology. Singaporean investors can choose to buy these stocks individually or through funds, but their high valuations present risks if market sentiment shifts.

Property: Singapore’s Cornerstone

Singapore’s property market is a cultural symbol, bolstered by a homeownership rate that exceeds 90% and the country’s political stability. Over the past 15 years, private residential prices have risen steadily, increasing by 60% despite government cooling measures such as the Additional Buyer’s Stamp Duty (ABSD). However, the high initial costs, ongoing maintenance expenses, and the illiquidity of property, where selling can take months, make real estate investment a significant commitment. While its tangible nature and prestige keep property a popular choice, it is crucial to assess whether it is the right option for you.

Personality Traits and Investment Choices

Your personality influences how you handle these options. Here’s how key traits align:

• Risk Tolerance
• Low: If Nasdaq’s rollercoaster rides or STI dips unnerve you, property’s stability might be your haven.
• High: Love the thrill of S&P 500 surges or Magnificent 7 growth spurts? Stocks could be your game.
• Patience and Time Horizon
• Long-term: The property’s slow appreciation suits patient investors who don’t mind waiting years.
• Flexible: Stocks—whether STI or Nasdaq—offer quick trades and adaptability for shorter goals.
• Hands-On Involvement
• Active: Enjoy managing tenants or renovations? Property’s your playground.
• Passive: Prefer set-it-and-forget-it? Index funds tracking the S&P 500 or STI are low-effort wins.
• Emotional Connection
• Tangible: Property’s physical presence feels grounding.
• Abstract: Stocks’ digital nature suits those who prioritise flexibility over touch.
• Social Recognition
• Status-Driven: In Singapore, a condo screams success.
• Low-Key: Stocks quietly build wealth without the spotlight.
• Knowledge and Expertise
• Real Estate Savvy: Know URA rules or HDB trends? Property’s your edge.
• Analytical: Love dissecting earnings or tech trends (hello, Magnificent 7)? Stocks are your canvas.
• Fear Management
• Panic-Prone: If a sudden market tumble (like a 10% Nasdaq drop) tempts you to sell frantically, property’s illiquidity can be a blessing—selling takes weeks or months, not a button click, preventing rash moves.
• Cool-Headed: If you stay calm during volatility, stocks’ liquidity lets you adjust strategically, capitalising on dips.
• Starting Capital
• Limited Funds: Lacking the 25% down payment for property? Stocks are accessible with just a few hundred dollars, letting you start small and grow.
• Substantial Savings: If you’ve got the capital for a property downpayment, you can leverage the property’s long-term appreciation.

Interactive Investment Personality Calculator

Property or Stock? Not sure where you lean? Try this assessment to find out!:

Real-Life Examples

• The Global Stock Enthusiast: Sarah is a 29-year-old tech worker who invests in the Nasdaq and the Magnificent Seven through exchange-traded funds (ETFs). She remains calm during market dips, starts with small investments, and appreciates the flexibility to sell quickly. Stocks align with her fearless approach and her preference for low capital investment.
• The Property Pragmatist: David is a 50-year-old manager who owns two condominiums. He is comfortable with large upfront costs and values the fact that he cannot sell impulsively during a market downturn. The stability and illiquidity of real estate suit his temperament, which tends to panic in volatile situations.

Beyond the Myths

Let’s debunk six common misconceptions—three for property and three for stocks—to guide your decision:

• Property Myths:
• “Property is always safer.” Not quite—rental voids, market slumps, or unexpected maintenance costs can hurt. High upfront costs and ABSD also add financial risk.
• “Property guarantees wealth.” While Singapore’s market is strong, high stamp duties, loan restrictions, and cooling measures can erode returns if not planned carefully.
• “You need to own multiple properties to succeed.” A single, well-chosen property can provide steady returns or rental income, especially if it aligns with your financial goals.
• Stock Myths:
• “Stocks are too foreign for Singaporeans.” With no capital gains tax and easy access to U.S. markets via local brokers, anyone can start small with Nasdaq ETFs or STI stocks.
• “Stocks are only for the young.” Age doesn’t dictate choice—retirees can use conservative strategies like dividend-focused STI stocks, while younger investors can chase Magnificent 7 growth.
• “Stocks are too risky to rely on.” Diversified portfolios, like S&P 500 ETFs, mitigate risk and have historically delivered strong long-term returns, often outpacing inflation.

Recommendations by Profile

• Risk-Averse Stabilizer: Property—or low-volatility STI blue chips for steady dividends.
• Bold Opportunist: Nasdaq or Magnificent 7 for high-growth bets.
• Busy Professional: S&P 500 ETFs for passive, low-effort gains.
• Engaged Controller: Property, with a dash of STI stocks for diversification.
• Balanced Thinker: Blend property and global stocks (e.g., 60% property, 40% S&P 500).

Final Thoughts

Investing goes beyond mere numbers; it’s a reflection of who you are. Do you find your pulse quickening at the thought of Nasdaq’s tech giants, or do you prefer the steady ascent of Singapore’s thriving property market? Take the time to reflect on your unique personality and explore a range of markets, from the STI to the Magnificent 7, to uncover the opportunities that resonate with you.

Stay ahead in Singapore’s vibrant real estate landscape by joining our mailing list or connecting with us on WhatsApp and Telegram. Gain exclusive insights that empower you to make well-informed decisions. If you’re eager to discover the latest property opportunities, delve into our new condo launches, each one a potential gem that could align perfectly with your investment journey.

Whether you’re interested in stocks, property, or a blend of both, it’s time to start building your wealth in a way that suits you best. Engage with a financial or real estate advisor to refine your strategy and take confident strides toward your financial goals. The journey to your ideal investment is awaiting you!